Here are the all-time major league leader boards (including the 1871-1875 National Association) after the 1900 season and after the 1919 season. So these tables show how the all-time Top Ten in each category changed during the Deadball Era.
Batting Games includes games played only as a baserunner but not games played only as a pitcher-fielder or only as a fielder, so it might be called games played on offense. Plate Appearances is the sum of At Bats, Bases on Balls, and first bases on Hit by Pitch. It some seasons, that differs from plate appearances by sacrifice bunts or flies and first base on balk or interference. Bold face highlights those 1900 leaders who were still leaders after 1919.
Batting Games
G to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 2523 Honus Wagner 2792
Bid McPhee 2135 Cap Anson 2523
Jim O'Rourke 1998 Sam Crawford 2517
Roger Connor 1997 Nap Lajoie 2480
John Ward 1825 Bill Dahlen 2443
Tom Brown 1786 Jake Beckley 2386
Jimmy Ryan 1778 Bobby Wallace 2383
George Van Haltren 1741 George Davis 2368
Jack Glasscock 1736 Lave Cross 2275
Germany Smith 1710 Fred Clarke 2242
Plate Appearances (estimate)
PA to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 11319 Honus Wagner 11739
Bid McPhee 9409 Cap Anson 11319
Jim O'Rourke 9047 Sam Crawford 10594
Roger Connor 8837 Jake Beckley 10470
Tom Brown 8182 Nap Lajoie 10460
Jimmy Ryan 8092 Bill Dahlen 10390
John Ward 8084 George Davis 10151
George Van Haltren 7953 Fred Clarke 9819
Dan Brouthers 7653 Lave Cross 9710
Ed McKean 7610 Bobby Wallace 9612
At Bats
AB to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 10277 Honus Wagner 10430
Jim O'Rourke 8501 Cap Anson 10277
Bid McPhee 8291 Nap Lajoie 9589
Roger Connor 7794 Sam Crawford 9570
John Ward 7647 Jake Beckley 9526
Tom Brown 7363 Lave Cross 9072
Jimmy Ryan 7243 Bill Dahlen 9031
George Van Haltren 7110 George Davis 9031
Paul Hines 7062 Tommy Corcoran 8804
Jack Glasscock 7030 Bobby Wallace 8618
Hits
H to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 3418 Cap Anson 3418
Jim O'Rourke 2642 Honus Wagner 3415
Roger Connor 2467 Nap Lajoie 3242
Dan Brouthers 2296 Sam Crawford 2961
George Van Haltren 2255 Willie Keeler 2932
Bid McPhee 2250 Jake Beckley 2930
Jimmy Ryan 2238 Jesse Burkett 2850
Ed Delahanty 2174 Ty Cobb 2713 (active)
Hugh Duffy 2171 Fred Clarke 2672
Paul Hines 2134 George Davis 2660
Doubles
2B to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 581 Nap Lajoie 657
Jim O'Rourke 465 Honus Wagner 640
Dan Brouthers 460 Cap Anson 581
Roger Connor 441 Ed Delahanty 522
Ed Delahanty 430 Jake Beckley 473
Paul Hines 399 Jim O'Rourke 465
Jimmy Ryan 394 Dan Brouthers 460
King Kelly 359 Sam Crawford 458
Harry Stovey 347 George Davis 451
Sam Thompson 340 Jimmy Ryan 451
Triples
3B to 1900 to 1919
Roger Connor 233 Sam Crawford 309
Dan Brouthers 205 Honus Wagner 252
Jake Beckley 188 Jake Beckley 243
Bid McPhee 188 Roger Connor 233
Buck Ewing 178 Fred Clarke 220
Harry Stovey 174 Ty Cobb 210 (active)
Mike Tiernan 162 Dan Brouthers 205
Sam Thompson 159 Joe Kelley 194
Ed McKean 158 Bid McPhee 188
Ed Delahanty 154 Ed Delahanty 185
Home Runs
HR to 1900 to 1919
Roger Connor 138 Roger Connor 138
Sam Thompson 127 Sam Thompson 127
Harry Stovey 122 Harry Stovey 122
Mike Tiernan 106 Gavy Cravath 118 (active)
Dan Brouthers 106 Jimmy Ryan 118
Jimmy Ryan 105 Hugh Duffy 106
Hugh Duffy 104 Dan Brouthers 106
Cap Anson 97 Mike Tiernan 106
Fred Pfeffer 94 Ed Delahanty 101
Herman Long 86 Honus Wagner 101
Bases on Balls
BB to 1900 to 1919
Billy Hamilton 1123 Billy Hamilton 1187
Roger Connor 1002 Jimmy Sheckard 1135
Cap Anson 983 Bill Dahlen 1064
Bid McPhee 981 Roy Thomas 1042
Cupid Childs 961 Jesse Burkett 1029
Dummy Hoy 877 Donie Bush 1007
Dan Brouthers 840 Dummy Hoy 1004
Mike Griffin 809 Miller Huggins 1003
Billy Nash 803 Roger Connor 1002
Paul Radford 790 Cupid Childs 991
Hit Batsmen
HB to 1900 to 1919
Tommy Tucker 272 Hughie Jennings 287
Hughie Jennings 263 Tommy Tucker 272
Curt Welch 173 Dan McGann 230
Jake Beckley 150 Jake Beckley 183
Steve Brodie 118 Curt Welch 173
Dummy Hoy 116 Kid Elberfeld 165
John McGraw 111 Fred Clarke 153
Bill Joyce 108 Bill Dahlen 140
Dan McGann 105 Frank Chance 137
Dan Brouthers 105 Nap Lajoie 134
Dummy Hoy 134
John McGraw 134
Runs Scored
R to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 1996 Cap Anson 1996
Jim O'Rourke 1728 Honus Wagner 1736
Bid McPhee 1678 Jim O'Rourke 1729
Roger Connor 1620 Jesse Burkett 1720
Billy Hamilton 1619 Willie Keeler 1719
Dan Brouthers 1523 Billy Hamilton 1690
Tom Brown 1521 Bid McPhee 1678
Jimmy Ryan 1508 Jimmy Ryan 1642
George Van Haltren 1501 George Van Haltren 1639
Hugh Duffy 1495 Roger Connor 1620
Runs Batted In
RBI to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 2076 Cap Anson 2076
Roger Connor 1322 Honus Wagner 1732
Dan Brouthers 1296 Nap Lajoie 1599
Sam Thompson 1296 Jake Beckley 1575
Hugh Duffy 1249 Sam Crawford 1525
Ed Delahanty 1242 Ed Delahanty 1464
Jim O'Rourke 1203 George Davis 1437
Jake Beckley 1171 Lave Cross 1371
Ed McKean 1124 Roger Connor 1322
Bid McPhee 1067 Hugh Duffy 1302
Sacrifice Hits
SH to 1900 to 1919
Herman Long 110 Willie Keeler 350
Bones Ely 108 Eddie Collins 332 (active)
Fred Tenney 98 Ray Chapman 293 (active)
Dummy Hoy 93 Jimmy Sheckard 286
Willie Keeler 91 Joe Tinker 285
Tommy Corcoran 88 Jack Barry 284
Hughie Jennings 86 Frank Schulte 279
Cupid Childs 85 Jake Daubert 276 (active)
Claude Ritchey 83 Fred Tenney 275
Bobby Lowe 82 Terry Turner 268
Stolen Bases
SB to 1900 to 1919
Billy Hamilton 892 Billy Hamilton 912
Arlie Latham 738 Ty Cobb 765 (active)
Tom Brown 657 Arlie Latham 739
Bid McPhee 568 Honus Wagner 722
Hugh Duffy 559 Tom Brown 657
Dummy Hoy 556 George Davis 616
John Ward 540 Dummy Hoy 594
George Van Haltren 539 George Van Haltren 583
Harry Stovey 509 Hugh Duffy 574
Herman Long 476 Bid McPhee 568
Extra-Base Hits
EBH to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 820 Honus Wagner 993
Roger Connor 812 Nap Lajoie 903
Dan Brouthers 771 Sam Crawford 864
Jim O'Rourke 678 Cap Anson 820
Ed Delahanty 666 Roger Connor 812
Jimmy Ryan 646 Ed Delahanty 808
Harry Stovey 643 Jake Beckley 802
Sam Thompson 626 Dan Brouthers 771
Jake Beckley 586 Jimmy Ryan 726
Paul Hines 549 Ty Cobb 708 (active)
Total Bases
TB to 1900 to 1919
Cap Anson 4574 Honus Wagner 4862
Roger Connor 3788 Cap Anson 4574
Jim O'Rourke 3595 Nap Lajoie 4474
Dan Brouthers 3484 Sam Crawford 4328
Jimmy Ryan 3241 Jake Beckley 4147
Ed Delahanty 3158 Ed Delahanty 3791
Bid McPhee 3088 Roger Connor 3788
George Van Haltren 3018 Ty Cobb 3765 (active)
Sam Thompson 3011 Jesse Burkett 3759
Hugh Duffy 3006 Fred Clarke 3674
Acknowledgments. The source of underlying season statistics is The Baseball Database version 5.2 (lahman_52), 2005.