The original editors, John Thorn and Mark Rucker in 1984 and Frederick Ivor-Campbell in 1990, recommended more than 300 subjects. Here are the 44 recommended subjects who are not featured in either volume.
See an incomplete classification.
Bechtel, George Birdsall, Dave Boyle, Jack Carroll, Cliff Casey, Dan Corkhill, Pop Crane, Cannonball Daily, Con DeBost, Charles Dowd, Tommy Driscoll, Denny "[John F.] Driscoll" by Charlie Bevis Ely, Bones Farrell, Jack Freeman, Buck in progress for SABR BioProject Ganzel, Charlie Gelston, Joe Grim, John Hughes, Jim Irwin, Charlie Knight, Lon "Lon Knight" by Ralph Berger Kuehne, Willie Malone, Fergie Martin, Phonnie McFarland, Ed McMullin, John Mills, Everett Mulvey, Joe Nops, Jerry O'Brien, Pete Pabor, Charlie Peitz, Heinie Pinckney, George Purcell, Blondie Seymour, Cy "Cy Seymour" by Bill Kirwin Sommer, Joe Staley, Harry Stricker, Cub Taylor, Brewery Jack "Jack Taylor" by Peter Mancuso Tebeau, White Wings Turner, Tuck in progress for SABR BioProject Vaughn, Farmer Wadsworth, Lewis Waitt, Charles Wolters, Rynie
Played at high level before 1871 (* entirely before 1871) Bechtel, George Birdsall, Dave * DeBost, Charles * Gelston, Joe Malone, Fergie Martin, Phonnie McMullin, John Mills, Everett * O'Brien, Pete Pabor, Charlie * Wadsworth, Lewis Wolters, Rynie Played major league baseball entirely 1871-1889 Driscoll, Denny Farrell, Jack Knight, Lon Purcell, Blondie Waitt, Charles Played MLB in 1890 or later (* 1900 or later) Boyle, Jack Carroll, Cliff Casey, Dan Corkhill, Pop Crane, Cannonball Daily, Con * Dowd, Tommy * Ely, Bones * Freeman, Buck Ganzel, Charlie Grim, John * Hughes, Jim * Irwin, Charlie Kuehne, Willie * McFarland, Ed Mulvey, Joe * Nops, Jerry * Peitz, Heinie Pinckney, George Sommer, Joe Staley, Harry Stricker, Cub Taylor, Brewery Jack Tebeau, White Wings Turner, Tuck Vaughn, Farmer * Seymour, Cy