Here are the 289 featured subjects. 22 were also selected for Deadball Era biographies about ten years later. The original 19th century editors recommended 44 other subjects who did not attract biographers.
Adams, Doc Donovan, Patsy Latham, Arlie Richmond, J. Lee Addy, Robert Dorgan, Mike Leggett, Joe Richter, Francis Allison, Doug Doyle, Jack Leonard, Andrew Robinson, Wilbert Anson, A. C. Duffy, Hugh Lewis, Edward M. (Parson) Robinson, Yank Baldwin, Charles (Lady) Dunlap, Fred Loftus. Tom Robison, Frank Baldwin, Mark Dwyer, Frank Long, Herman Robison, Stanley Bancroft, Frank Eggler, Dave Lovett, Tom Rogers, Mort Barnes, Ross Ehret, Red Lowe, Bobby Rowe, Jack Barnie, Bill Esterbrook, Dude Lucas, Henry Rusie, Amos Beckley, Jake Ewing, Buck Lynch, Jack Ryan, Jimmy Bellan, Esteban Farrell, Charles (Duke) Lyons, Denny Sanders, Ben Bennett, Charlie Fennelly, Frank Mack, Connie Schriver, Pop Bergen, Martin Ferguson, Charlie Mains, Grasshopper Selbach, Kip Bierbauer, Louis Ferguson, Robert V. Manning, Jack Selee, Frank Bond, Tommy Fisler, West Mathews, Bobby Shaffer, Orator Borden, Joseph E. Flint, Silver McAleer, Jimmy Shaw, Dupee Bradley, George Fogarty, Jim McBride, Dick Shindle, Billy Brainard, Asa Force, Davey McCarthy, Tom Smith, Elmer E. Breitenstein, Ted Foutz, Dave McCormick, Harry Smith, Germany Brodie, Steve Fowler, Bud McCormick, Jim Smith, Pop Brouthers, Dan Fulmer, Chick McGeary, Mike Snyder, Pop Brown, Tom Gaffney, John McGill, Willie Sockalexis, Louis Browning, Pete Galvin, Jim McGinnis, George (Jumbo) Soden, Arthur Brush, J. T. Gerhardt, Joe McGraw, John Spalding, Al Buffinton, Charley Getzien, Charlie McGuire, James (Deacon) Spink, Al Bulkeley, Morgan Glasscock, Jack McKean, Ed Start, Joe Burdock, Jack Gleason, Bill McKinnon, Al Stein, Ed Burkett, Jesse Gleason, Kid McKnight, Denny Stenzel, Jake Burns, Oyster Goldsmith, Fred McLean, Billy Stivetts, Jack Burns, Tommy Gore, George McMahon, Sadie Stovey, George Bushong, Doc Grant, Frank McPhee, Bid Stovey, Harry Byrne, Charles H. Griffin, Mike McVey, Cal Stratton, Scott Callahan, Nixey Griffith, Clark Meekin, Jouett Sullivan, Ted Cammeyer, William Gumbert, Ad Mercer, Win Sunday, Billy Campau, Count Haddock, George Meyerle, Levi Sutton, Ezra Carpenter, Warren Hall, George Miller, Foghorn Swartwood, Ed Carroll, Fred Hallman, Bill Milligan, Jocko Sweeney, Bill Carsey, Kid Hamilton, Billy Mills, A. G. Sweeney, Charles Cartwright, Alexander Hankinson, Frank Morrill, John Taylor, Billy Caruthers, Bob Hanlon, Ned Morris, Ed Tebeau, Patsy Caylor, O. P. Hawley, Pink Mullane, Tony Tenney, Fred Chadwick, Henry Hecker, Guy Murnane, Tim Terry, Adonis Chamberlain, Elton Higham, Dick Mutrie, Jim Thompson, Sam Chapman, John C. Hines, Paul Nash, Billy Tiernan, Mike Childs, Cupid Hoffer, Billy Nelson, Candy Tucker, Tommy Clapp, John Holbert, Bill Nichols, Kid Tyng, Jim Clarke, Fred Holliday, Bug Nicol, Hugh Van Haltren, George Clarkson, John Hornung, Joe Nolan, The Only Von der Ahe, Chris Clements, John T. Hotaling, Pete O'Connor, Jack Von der Horst, Harry Collins, Hub Hoy, William (Dummy) O'Day, Hank Walker, Moses Fleetwood Collins, Jimmy Hulbert, William O'Neill, Tip Ward, Johnny Comiskey, Charlie Hurst, Tim O'Rourke, Jim Weidman, Stump Connor, Roger Hutchison, William F. Orr, Dave Welch, Curt Corcoran, Larry Irwin, Arthur Pearce, Dickey Welch, Mickey Corcoran, Tommy Jennings, Hugh Peters, John Werden, Perry Craver, Bill Jones, Charlie Pfeffer, Fred Weyhing, Gus Creighton, James Joyce, William M. Phillips, Bill White, James (Deacon) Cross, Lave Keefe, Tim Pike, Lipman White, Solomon Cummings, Candy Keeler, Wee Willie Pratt, Al White, Will Cunningham, Bert Kelley, Joe Pratt, Tom Whitney, Jim Cuppy, Nig Kelly, John Quest, Joseph Williamson, Ned Cuthbert, Ned Kelly, Mike (King) Quinn, Joe Wilmot, Walt Dahlen, Bill Kennedy, Bill Radbourne, Charlie Wise, Sam Daily, Hugh Kerins, John Radford, Paul Wolf, William (Chicken) Dalrymple, Abner Killen, Frank Ramsey, Toad Wood, George (Dandy) Daly, Tom Kilroy, Mathew Rankin, Will Wood, Jimmy Davis, George S. King, Charles (Silver) Reach, A. J. (Al) Wright, George Day, John B. Kittridge, Malachi Reilly, John Wright, Harry De Montreville, Eugene N. Klobedanz, Fred Reitz, Heinie York, Thomas J. Delahanty, Ed LaChance, Candy Rhines, Billy Young, Cy Denny, Jerry Lange, Bill Richardson, Danny Young, Nick Devlin, Jim Larkin, Henry E. Richardson, Hardie Zettlein, George Zimmer, Chief