From sj-approval@world.std.com  Mon Jun  1 03:46:13 1998
Return-Path: <sj-approval@world.std.com>
Received: from europe.std.com by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA17761; Sun, 31 May 1998 23:49:18 -0400
Received: by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id XAA01782; Sun, 31 May 1998 23:48:51 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from world.std.com by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id XAA01777; Sun, 31 May 1998 23:48:48 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from geocities.com (mail3.geocities.com) by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA17483; Sun, 31 May 1998 23:48:47 -0400
Received: from oemcomputer (166-93-39-94.rmi.net [166.93.39.94])
	by geocities.com (8.8.5/8.8.5) with SMTP id UAA28640
	for <sj@world.std.com>; Sun, 31 May 1998 20:47:24 -0700 (PDT)
Message-Id: <3.0.5.32.19980531214613.007b4aa0@mail.geocities.com>
X-Sender: john_meyer@mail.geocities.com
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Light Version 3.0.5 (32)
Date: Sun, 31 May 1998 21:46:13 -0600
To: sj@world.std.com
From: John Meyer <john_meyer@geocities.com>
Subject: RE: college newspaper recruitment
In-Reply-To: <199805312316.SAA10969@ux6.cso.uiuc.edu>
References: <3.0.5.32.19980531131418.007b6e70@mail.geocities.com>
 <Pine.3.07.9805311309.A8047-d100000@login>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Sender: sj-approval@world.std.com
Precedence: list
Reply-To: sj@world.std.com

>No way. When I graduated from high school, I already had worked for
>six years (since seventh grade) at the professional newspaper in my
>hometown. The summer before I enrolled in college, I worked as a
>wire service stringer covering a major murder trial that got
>statewide attention. That's quite a bit more than having worked on a
>high school paper, yet I didn't feel as if I had "paid my dues" 
>and as a result did not object when I was not allowed into
>journalism school or onto the student newspaper until I became a
>junior.
>
>Why? My experience was enough for me to recognize that I really
>didn't know nearly as much as I emotionally thought I did. In the
>years since then, I have seen literally hundreds of students who
>"paid their dues" in high school journalism courses come very close
>to failing their first college journalism courses. Your example is
>akin to saying that because you had health and biology classes in
>high school you should be able to go right into medical school in
>college. There's a bit more to it than you might, with limited
>experience, be able to detect.

Unfortunately, your analogy is off.  Journalism is not a practice, as some
would imagine.  Thankfully, there is no licensing requirement to write for
a newspaper.  You don't have to go to college to write for a paper, nor
should you.
As for paying my dues, I did not mean that the learning did not stop with
high school; I meant that I had reasonably done enough reporting to begin
learning more by doing than by thinking.  Journalism requires practice, it
doesn't require theory.

>One of the worst problems created by allowing untrained journalists
>to work on a college paper is that by the time they arrive in
>journalism courses, they tend to think they know everything. They
>start out doing a bit better than other students in their journalism
>classes, but rarely do they continue to improve. By the time they
>become seniors, it becomes obvious that having spent two or more
>years working in an undisciplined manner has damaged them every bit
>as much as if they had been an athlete who received improper
>coaching in his or her formative years.

Okay, let's take your scenario, and what happens.  I have a reasonable
portfolio and want to apply for the college newspaper, but the editors or
advisors tell me I don't have enough experience to write on the paper.  So,
what do I do?  Do I go to a few more news writing classes, wait for the day
to apply to j-school, and hope and pray that someday I will get the honor
of being on such a newspaper?  Hardly; I came to the university to write,
not to study the theory of writing, and if I can't do it at that
university, then I'll find another university.  Most likely, this is why so
many underground newspapers exists; they don't like elitists such as
yourself telling writers that they don't have the skills or the portfoilio
to be on a collge newspaper.  Maybe I'm misreading your attitude, but I
find it very hard to believe that anybody who wasn't a journalism student
and wasn't in the top ten percent of the class would be able to be on the
paper, at least under your policy.
I think we have a difference in opinion as to what a college newspaper is.
You think that a college newspaper is the equivalent of a professional
newspaper to be protected from people who haven't had enough experience.  I
think that a college newspaper is a learning, semi-professional newspaper. 
Maybe you are only referring to editor positions, and if you are, I could
agree with you there.  Having a mass communications major requirement, and
a number of years, on editor positions, would be acceptable.  What I would
not want to do is lock out journalists from a resource that allegedly
belongs to the whole school.
    ,dP""d8b,              John Meyer                                    
    d"   d88"8b            john_meyer@geocities.com                        
   I8    Y88a88)           TechBits Poderator
   `Y, a  )888P            http://members.tripod.com/~john_ludwig_meyer
    "b,,a88P"                                                         

"Anyone who fights for the future, lives in it today" -Ayn Rand

