From sj-approval@world.std.com  Mon Jun  1 00:16:21 1998
Return-Path: <sj-approval@world.std.com>
Received: from europe.std.com by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA00512; Sun, 31 May 1998 19:16:35 -0400
Received: by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id TAA07644; Sun, 31 May 1998 19:16:29 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from world.std.com by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id TAA07637; Sun, 31 May 1998 19:16:26 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from ux6.cso.uiuc.edu by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA00464; Sun, 31 May 1998 19:16:26 -0400
Received: from meyer (london-8.slip.uiuc.edu [130.126.26.68])
	by ux6.cso.uiuc.edu (8.8.8/8.8.8) with SMTP id SAA10988
	for <sj@world.std.com>; Sun, 31 May 1998 18:16:22 -0500 (CDT)
Message-Id: <199805312316.SAA10988@ux6.cso.uiuc.edu>
From: "Eric Meyer" <meyer@newslink.org>
Organization: NewsLink Associates
To: sj@world.std.com
Date: Sun, 31 May 1998 18:16:21 -0600
Subject: RE: college newspaper recruitment
References: <199805282245.RAA10601@ux6.cso.uiuc.edu>
In-Reply-To: <Pine.3.07.9805311309.A8047-d100000@login>
Sender: sj-approval@world.std.com
Precedence: list
Reply-To: sj@world.std.com

At 13:45 on 31 May 98, Andy Gammill  wrote in part:

> As to having the clear-cut advancing hierarchy, that is definitely a
> must. However, I disagree that only a journalism student can make it
> through that hierarchy. 

I never said that only a journalism student should be considered. (Go 
back and check the original post.) I did, however, say that a 
student should be required to have some basic journalistic experience 
before starting up the ladder as a reporter. 

Typically, this means at least an introductory reporting course (most 
universities have something like this that even non-majors can take). 
In some unusual cases, outside work experience -- something beyond 
having worked on a high school newspaper -- could substitute.

Often, a requirement such as this has the effect of reduceing the 
number of non-journalism majors working at a student newspaper. The 
goal, however, is not to ban them but rather to insist on having a 
competent, mature, well-qualified staff.

> (Recent surveys show something like 70 percent of the editors of
> major newspapers prefer students without a journalism degree.)

That's a very serious misstatement of what the surveys have said. 
Both the number and the conclusion are almost completely wrong. I 
suggest you read a report like Betty Medsger's "The Winds of Change" 
to understand what the surveys really say.

What editors value most is an ability to do the job well. This 
includes such things as having a well-rounded education apart from 
journalism training. Such concerns explain why ACCREDITED journalism 
programs LIMIT the number of hours a student may take in journalism 
classes and require educational concentrations in other areas. One 
way that typically helps accomplish this is not to allow admission 
to journalism until the student's junior year.

To be sure, a journalism degree, particularly one from a 
non-accredited school, does not automatically qualify anyone for any 
position. Nor, however, does it automatically disqualify anyone, as 
this comment suggests. In fact, techniques and, in particular, 
critical thinking skills taught by a journalism curriculum are highly 
valued by hiring editors. So, too, are such things as breadth of  
education outside of journalism, general writing abilities, 
internships, student publication experience and other factors.

What concerns me most is that many students come to a university,
work as untrained student journalists in their freshman and
sophomore years, get so involved in the student newspaper that their
grades aren't good enough to transfer into J school, then use a
misquote like the one above to justify their situation. In fact,
their own over-emphasis on student media work may be the exact type 
of problem that spurred hiring editors' initial concerns about 
journalism degrees.

I am not saying that the writer of the note to which I am responding 
is a person of this sort. I am saying, however, that I have seen far 
too many such people at other student newspapers. Amazingly 
enough, almost all of those papers have been struggling with the 
problem that begat this exchange -- an inability to attract top 
journalism students to the newspaper staff. Meanwhile, other papers, 
which employ a system more like the one I mentioned, seldom have such 
problems and are even more likely to win "top paper" honors than the 
newspaper this student mentioned.





 



----------------------------------------------------
  N E W S L I N K                    Eric K. Meyer  
  research and consulting         Managing partner  
----------------------------------------------------
* DESIGNING INFOGRAPHICS: Preview definitive new    
  how-to book at http://www.newslink.org/book.html  
* TOMORROW'S NEWS TODAY: For free sample of newly   
  revised, critically acclaimed strategic guide     
  for online publishers, write report@newslink.org  
* AJR NEWSLINK: Visit the web's top media resource, 
  with 7,000 links, including more newspaper links
  than any other site, at http://www.newslink.org       

