From sj-approval@world.std.com  Sun May 31 19:14:18 1998
Return-Path: <sj-approval@world.std.com>
Received: from europe.std.com by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA16766; Sun, 31 May 1998 15:16:27 -0400
Received: by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id PAA19467; Sun, 31 May 1998 15:16:01 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from world.std.com by europe.std.com (8.7.6/BZS-8-1.0)
	id PAA19459; Sun, 31 May 1998 15:15:58 -0400 (EDT)
Received: from geocities.com (mail8.geocities.com) by world.std.com (TheWorld/Spike-2.0)
	id AA16538; Sun, 31 May 1998 15:15:57 -0400
Received: from oemcomputer (166-93-38-137.rmi.net [166.93.38.137])
	by geocities.com (8.8.5/8.8.5) with SMTP id MAA05975
	for <sj@world.std.com>; Sun, 31 May 1998 12:12:08 -0700 (PDT)
Message-Id: <3.0.5.32.19980531131418.007b6e70@mail.geocities.com>
X-Sender: john_meyer@mail.geocities.com
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Light Version 3.0.5 (32)
Date: Sun, 31 May 1998 13:14:18 -0600
To: sj@world.std.com
From: John Meyer <john_meyer@geocities.com>
Subject: RE: college newspaper recruitment
In-Reply-To: <Pine.3.07.9805311309.A8047-d100000@login>
References: <199805282245.RAA10601@ux6.cso.uiuc.edu>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Sender: sj-approval@world.std.com
Precedence: list
Reply-To: sj@world.std.com

>On Thu, 28 May 1998, Eric Meyer wrote:
>
>> There's a vicious cycle that affects campus papers, and about the 
>> only way to combat it is to be willing to stick with a plan for 
>> several years, whatever the cost.
>> 
>> If you want top journalism students to volunteer for the paper, what 
>> you need is a clear, advancing hierarchy that rewards and promotes 
>> them. Why would a journalism senior choose to work as a reporter for 
>> a sub-editor who's a sophomore chemistry major? He or she might, but 
>> not for long. If incoming staff members do not professionally respect 
>> those above them in the paper's hierarchy, they will quickly leave 
>> and dismiss the paper in such a way as to make their peers unlikely 
>> to volunteer in the future.

For starters, if the skills of the journalism senior are so lack that he or
she cannot obtain an editorship, why would you even want that person on
your paper?  I would assume that if you were into journalism, at least you
would have experience on the paper, enough so that you could get a position
as an editor, or at least a senior reporter.
I think the chemistry example would be a bit extreme, but let's take that
point out.  If the only editors that gain respect are those going on to a
journalism degree, then how come so many people have made it in our field
without much more than a high school degree?  What about English majors?
The example that often happens in our university is that the editors are
themselves reporters.  You get respect through your clippings, not through
your title as "managing editor" or "sports editor" or whatever.
 
>> Key to resolving this, in my view, is adherence to a very strict path 
>> of advancement. First you cover student housing or whatever, then you 
>> are an assistant assignment editor, then you become the assigment 
>> editor and finally you become editor in chief.

The two problems with that are that no two people go the same route.  You
might have somebody who is great at sports, but not so great at student
housing, and another reporter who's vice versa.
I would say that you start by having every reporter do a little bit of
everything.  Then, after the reporter has found his or her niche (or maybe
finds out that reporting is not for them), then you steer them into an area.
 
>> Personally, I would not allow freshmen and first-semester sophomores 
>> to work on the paper. Some classroom experience in reporting should 
>> be a prerequisite for a job. Then, change positions frequently, 
>> having no more than a single semester of tenure for any position. 
>> Reporting beats might change at mid-semester every fall and spring. 
>> Editing positions might change at every semester break.

Just one problem with that position, though.  By doing that, you are
forgetting the people who have paid their dues by going through high school
learning about the factual journalism journalism.  One of the things I
"learned" during my first semester at the University of Southern Colorado
was that you had to wait two years before applying to the journalism
college at the University of Colorado-Boulder (if there are any students
from the University of Colorado on this list, and if that fact is wrong,
please tell me).  In any case, waiting two years for somebody to tell me
that I was ready to report was not what I wanted.  I want to write, and I
want to write as soon as possible.  The point is this: I have reported for
four years now, and I did not learn one thing in News Writing 101 that has
not  been slammed into my head since then.  News Writing helped reinforce
those necessary points to being a journalist, but ultimately, nothing new
there.
Also, being a journalist is something whose facts you can teach, but not
the truth.  I can teach you the fifteen elements of a good news story, and
I can tell you the essentials of the AP book, but I can't tell you how that
all binds together into a great story.  That's something you have to find
out by doing. 
>> 
>> Treat the student newspaper like a business, not a club. The 
>> publisher of the Chicago Tribune isn't going to pick a social 
>> friend of his with no journalistic experience to serve as editor. 
>> Likewise, the new city editor is probably going be the reporter who 
>> did the best before the position opened up.
>> 
>> If necessary, bite the bullet and go without rather than promote 
>> someone who does not have the credentials for the job. Most 
>> important, don't insist on stupid things like requiring the staff to 
>> forgo summer internships so they can put out a summer session 
>> edition.

This part I do agree with.  The editor eventually has to end up picking the
best person for the best job.  I just don't agree with the results.  The
best person for the job might end up having somebody cover basketball for
four years because he or she has a great relationship with the coach and/or
some of the players.
	Essentially, to answer the original question about recruiting staff, look
for consistancy rather than one "really good" staff.  If we can put out a
good paper nine out of ten times and have one bad paper, rather than
putting out one Pulitzer Prize edition, then so be it.  Same with a staff;
the people in journalism ultimately are there to learn how to put out a
paper, and they are going to have mistakes.  What you have to tell your
recruits is that this is a learning process.  If you tell them that you
expect a paper to rival the L.A. Times, your going to scare off most of
your staff real fast.
    ,dP""d8b,              John Meyer                                    
    d"   d88"8b            john_meyer@geocities.com                        
   I8    Y88a88)           TechBits Poderator
   `Y, a  )888P            http://members.tripod.com/~john_ludwig_meyer
    "b,,a88P"                                                         

"Anyone who fights for the future, lives in it today" -Ayn Rand

