From sj-approval@facteur.std.com  Fri Feb 14 19:00:49 1997
Return-Path: <sj-approval@facteur.std.com>
Received: from europe.std.com by world.std.com (5.65c/Spike-2.0)
	id AA03599; Fri, 14 Feb 1997 14:02:48 -0500
Received: by europe.std.com (8.7.5/BZS-8-1.0)
	id OAA05187; Fri, 14 Feb 1997 14:00:54 -0500 (EST)
X-Authentication-Warning: europe.std.com: daemon set sender to sj-approval using -f
Received: from world.std.com by europe.std.com (8.7.5/BZS-8-1.0)
	id OAA05177; Fri, 14 Feb 1997 14:00:52 -0500 (EST)
Received: from bang.jmk.su.se by world.std.com (5.65c/Spike-2.0)
	id AA01994; Fri, 14 Feb 1997 14:00:51 -0500
Received: from [130.237.155.24] (Stora_Red_14 [130.237.155.24]) by bang.jmk.su.se (8.7.6/8.6.6) with SMTP id UAA09483 for <sj@world.com>; Fri, 14 Feb 1997 20:00:49 +0100 (MET)
X-Sender: o-steron@130.237.155.254
Message-Id: <v02140b00af2a66bfc649@[130.237.155.20]>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Date: Fri, 14 Feb 1997 20:00:49 +0100
To: sj@world.std.com
From: o-steron@jmk.su.se (Ron van der Sterren)
Subject: Is music journalism real journalism?
Sender: sj-approval@world.std.com
Precedence: list
Reply-To: sj@facteur.std.com

Hi,

I'm a Dutch journalist, working  for a Dutch/Belgian music magazine called
"RifRaf" (and currently following a course 'Global Electronic Journalism'
at the Stockholm university). I'm trying to work on the answer of the
following question: Is music journalism real journalism? Because ther is no
"yes" or "no"-answer on this question I would like to start a discussion on
this question. What do you think(I just write down some questions that can
be used as a starting point for the discussion. (again, I don't want a
'yes' or a 'no', but your view on it (if possible with references) :
Is a music journalist controlled by the record companies? Is a music
journalist not too often a music freak who learned how to write at High
School, but doesn't know anything about journalistic skills? Is this bad,
or is it providing a different (fresh) view on the subject of (pop)music?
Do hobbywriters rule musicland? Isn't it possible to write a good review,
as they do about books, classical perfomances (is this true?), or is the
way of writing about popmusic part of the popculture?

I'm not only interested in the debate (maybe to enhance music journalism
itself), I'm also going to write an essay about it. I tried to find some
information by using a couple of searchtools, but the only things it pumped
up were reviews and interviews, not the articles I'm looking for articles
about criticism on music journalism, or people who have criticism on the
music journalism, or of course people who have the complete opposite view
on this matter an can explain to me why they are right.

A little story to explain the birth of this question:

For years I dreamed of it. Write and most of all be with famous musicians.
Like other reviewwriters I'm quite an unfortunate musician who tries to be
a part of the scene via another way.

Even bigger was my dissapointment when I did my first interview with a
'big' band. I got wet dreams of the idea that I was going to speak with
this musician. I had visions of two musicians talking about music all
night. But then reality woke me up again. I wasn't a musician who was going
to meetanother musician in a bar. I was a journalist, provided with one
lousy biography from which I could extract a few stupid questions (the ones
that all the other music journalists in all other countries where this band
played asked). I got half an hour to do my thing, and then the next
magazine would throw its notationmaker in the room.

Of course one could opt that I wasn't prepared good enough, and I have to
admit that that was probably the case. But that makes it even more sad.
Afterwards I felt having done a real bad interview. We didn't talk about
anything interesting. But when I compared my story with the stories of
other journalists who had interviewed this band, they didn't have anything
I didn't have. It was only my first time, and I already had the settings
you need to write an acceptable story for a music magazine........Is this
the way it moslty goes; you get the cd, a poor biography, you combine that
with your own knowledge and of you go? And if it is, why do we call this
storymaking business journalism?

I hope this is enough feedback to get it started.

thanks
bij voorbaat dank
Tak

Ron van der Sterren
temporary adres (till june)
Forskarbacken 11/306
104 05 Stockholm
e-mail: o-steron@jmk.su.se


