Documentaries
** Highly Recommended **
West
of Memphis, dir
by Amy Berg © 2012
Three
eight-year-old boys were murdered in West Memphis, Arkansas in 1993 and three
teen-aged boys were convicted of the murders. I had seen previous documentaries
(Paradise Lost & Paradise Lost 2) on this case, but those
are not at all necessary background for this film. Information is slowly revealed
about who the actual murderer might have been. Fascinating! Our justice system
leaves a lot to be desired! The convicted boys lost 18 years of their lives on
a wrongful conviction.
56 Up, dir by Michael Apted © 2012 B
Library
CD. The lads and lasses who were seven in 1963 are now 56. I still love hearing
the clips of what they said when they were seven! See Ebert’s interview with
the director in Misc section, below.
The Topp Twins: Untouchable Girls, dir by Leanne Pooley © 2009 B
Library DVD. Eva highly recommended this a few years ago. Bob loved it, but I
was less enthusiastic. Though I admired their comedic gifts and chutzpah, a
little of their character impersonations went a long way. I know it was
necessary for the film to show that, or we wouldn’t know what they were famous
and beloved for, in New Zealand. Truthfully, this would not have ranked among
my Highly Recommended were it not for the 24-minute extra feature. The twins
were interviewed and talked about their childhood. I loved that. I agree with
Tim Finn when he says (in one of the extra interviews) “they’re just firing off
each other; you’re just left in their wake.” Good stuff.
Edie & Thea: A Very Long Engagement, dir by Susan Muska and Greta Olafsdottir © 2009 B
Library DVD. The directors
also made The Brandon Teena Story.
In October, Eva suggested that I read an article in The New Yorker. The article was about Edie Windsor. When her
spouse, Thea Spyer, died of MS, Edie had to pay inheritance tax, even though
the two women had been legally married. The United States Supreme Court held (on
26 June 2013) that restricting U.S. federal interpretation of "marriage"
and "spouse" to apply only to heterosexual unions was
unconstitutional. The Court said that the Due Process Clause of the Fifth
Amendment made Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) unconstitutional.
The article referenced this film, which is how I happened to seek it out. Postscript:
Edith Windsor was one of the final ten contenders for Time Magazine’s Person of the Year. (Pope Francis got the top
honor, but Edith Windsor, unlikely activist, came in #3.)
Forks Over Knives, dir by Lee Fulkerson © 2011
Library
DVD. Makes the case against the
consumption of meat and dairy. Much of the documentary focuses on the work of
Drs. Caldwell Esselstyn and Colin Campbell.
** Also Worth Seeing **
Clinton, dir by Barack Goodman © 2012 B
Library
DVD. Part of the American Experience
PBS series (aired Spring, 2012). Always interesting to look back over history
you have lived through.
The Queen of Versailles, dir by Lauren Greenfield © 2012 B
Library
DVD. OK, I know Downton Abbey is
fiction, and this is documentary, but one cannot help but be struck by how the nouveau riche (seen in this movie) do
not know how to handle wealth (unlike the Downton
Abbey crowd). Two small examples: Jacqueline having her chauffeur stop at
McDonald’s, and her shopping spree. Conspicuous consumption at its most sickening.
Worth seeing if you can stomach it.
The Invisible War, dir by Kirby Dick © 2012 B
About
women (and some men) in the military being raped by men in the military. Most
do not report it. Reactions that women got, when they did come forward varied
from, “He was taking advantage of a situation. There’s a difference between
that and rape,” to “Where’s your proof?” to “Do you really want to ruin his
career?” These women had wanted nothing more than to serve their country. The
reality shattered their idealism. I’m glad this was documented, and sometimes
it was heartbreaking, but as a film, this was not that great. There was no
progression, no surprise. As of Dec, 2013, Senator Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY)
has a bill before Congress that would “transfer the commander’s power to decide
who will be court-martialed for serious offenses to lawyers outside the chain
of command (except for core military offenses, like desertion and disobedience).”
We will be watching that closely.
The Human Scale, dir by Andreas M. Dalsgaard B
Part
of Rochester’s Greentopia festival, with panel discussion afterwards. Filmmaker
statement: “I want to portray the human being within the built environment. The
Danish architect Jan Gehl, and the people inspired by him, work with people
rather than buildings. The space between the buildings, as they call it.” Basically,
this was a depressing cataloging of extremely-fast-growing cities (Chongqing in
China, and Dhaka in Bangladesh, for example) and all the human misery (high
rises, garbage, traffic) that is inherent in this trend. City planners who were
acolytes of Denmark’s Jan Gehl were interviewed. But talk about an uphill
battle!
Irena Sendler, In the Name of Their
Mothers, dir by Mary Skinner
Library
DVD. Over seven years, director Mary Skinner recorded over 70 hours of
interview material and consulted archives, historical experts, and eyewitnesses
in the United States and Poland. Includes interviews with three of Sendler's
co-workers and several of the (now grown) Jewish children they saved. The film
features the last interviews Sendler gave before her death in 2008 at the age
of 98. This aired on PBS in May, 2011.
Soul of a People: Writing America's Story © 2009
Library
DVD about the Federal Writers’ Project. Was aired on the Smithsonian Channel
and funded by The National Endowment for the Humanities. It is narrated by
Patricia Clarkson, and features one of the last interviews with Studs Terkel.
Douglas Brinkley is also interviewed. The Writers’ Project had to draw 90% of
its workers from the unemployed, and it made them sign a pauper's oath. See
Movie Misc section.
Inequality for All, dir by Jacob Kornbluth © 2013 B
Robert
Reich was U.S. Labor Secretary under Bill Clinton. Here he talks straight to
the camera and is also seen teaching his Wealth and Poverty class. The first 30
years of my life coincide exactly with what Reich calls "The Great Prosperity" (1947–77),
when wages rose while companies expanded, jobs were plentiful and college was affordable
or free.
The Trials of Muhammad Ali, dir by Bill Siegel © 2013 B
Dryden
Theatre. Concentrates on the period when Ali was convicted of draft evasion. He felt he had more in common
with the people he was being asked to kill rather than those doing the asking.
(As he famously put it, "No Viet Cong ever called me 'n****r.'") He
was sentenced to five years in prison,
fined $10,000 and banned from boxing for three years. (He stayed out of prison
as his case was appealed.) Includes interviews with Ali’s brother, one of his
ex-wives (Khalilah
Camacho-Ali) and Louis Farrakhan. Bill Siegel previously
co-directed The Weather Underground
(2002; we saw it in 2006).
** I Might Have Skipped These **
Speak, dir by Paul Galichia and Brian Weidling © 2012
Follows
the participants in the 2008 Toastmasters World Championship of Public
Speaking. This film was not about the fear of public speaking (except for a few
interviews at the beginning). It is about the lives of two participants, in
particular. One of them was Rich, who had six children, a job that didn’t pay
the bills, and a very supportive wife. Her support enabled him to follow his
dream, which was, frankly, unrealistic. He was focused on winning because his
dream (not very well thought through, in my opinion) was that winning would
result in so many invitations to speak that his money worries would be over.
***************************************************
TV Series
Upstairs, Downstairs, Season 5
Library
DVD. Season 5 spans twelve years, 1919 through 1930. This Edwardian drama
finished airing in 1977, which is, amazingly, 35 years ago. I never saw it
then, but in the last couple of years I have watched the entire series. In the
final episode, the Bellamys were leaving 165 Eaton Place, son James having been
ruined in the stock market. Georgina and Lord Stockbridge get married and go
off to a new life, bringing Daisy and Edward with them. Angus Hudson and Kate
Bridges will run a seaside boarding house, and Richard and Virginia go off to a
quiet life in the country, bringing Rose with them. I’m so glad I finally saw
this series!
Downton Abbey, Season 3 B
Created
and principally written by Julian Fellowes. Since we don’t have PBS, we bought
this season from Amazon in January, just weeks after it aired. The first
episode of Season 4 aired this holiday season, so we will catch up with that in
2014.
The Killing, Season 2 B
Library
DVD. In December 2012, we finished the first season and in 2013 we moved on to
Season 2. We will probably go on to Season 3 in 2014.
Mad Men, Season 5
Library
DVD. Watched the whole season between Nov, 2012 and Feb, 2013. I continue to
enjoy this series, and in December have begun watching Season 6.
Foyle’s War, Seasons 3, 4 and 5 B
Library
DVD. Set in 1941 and 1942, then skips quickly through ‘43-‘45. Was broadcast in
the U.S. on Mystery! beginning in
Sept 2005. The
stories told are grounded in truth (use of carborundum powder to disable cars,
land girls working for 28 shillings a week in 1941, shipyards embezzling funds,
etc). We love Michael Kitchen as Christopher Foyle, and Honeysuckle Weeks as
Sam Stewart. When Bob’s sister Ann came for a week in August, we sent two
episodes back with her to Sutton, and she and Rodney enjoyed them very much. We
also bought the whole first season and gave it to Mary Susan Black when we visited
in July. (Season 5 was going to be the end of the series, but later the cast
came together for some post-war episodes, and so we have more seasons to look
forward to.)
Homeland, Season 1 B
Library
DVD. This is a Showtime series from 2011. We finished Season 1 in March. The
continuing adventures of Carrie, Saul, and Brody!
To Serve Them All My Days, Season 1 B
Library DVD. Produced by BBC-TV
in 2003, based on the book by R. F. Delderfield. After being wounded in WWI, Welshman
David Powlett-Jones arrives at a British boarding school run by Headmaster
Herries.
Call the Midwife, Seasons 1 & 2
Library DVD. Series created
and written by Heidi Thomas, based on trilogy of memoirs by Jennifer Worth, who
wrote about her work as a midwife practicing in the poverty-stricken East End
of London in the 1950s. I thoroughly enjoyed the first two seasons. I think the
nuns are pretty realistically portrayed.
Grey’s Anatomy, Seasons 1 and 2
Library
DVD. I don’t know what made me try this ABC series. Season 1 aired in 2005. I
really like Chandra Wilson in her role as Miranda Bailey. I have gotten pretty
hooked on this. Shondra Rhimes, series creator, says that she found the idea of a show
about smart women competing against one another an interesting one.
***************************************************
Narrative Films
** Some of this actually happened **
Lincoln, dir
by Steven Spielberg B
Marvelous.
Saw this early in the year. Then in Oct I began reading Team of Rivals. After finishing that I intend to watch this film
again. This and 42 are my only 2013
film in the non-documentary, non-TV-series category that I highly
recommend. The rest in this category I deem to be Also Worth Seeing, but not
Must See.
42, written and directed by Brian
Helgeland B
Brian Helgeland also wrote the screenplay (from a
Dennis Lahane novel) for Mystic River
and L.A. Confidential (from a James
Ellroy novel). I’d say now, with the writing and directing credit on 42, he’s surely cemented his
credentials. Jackie Robinson’s first day in the major Leagues was April 15, 1947,
when he was 28, and he played through the ’56 season. Those were the years of
my childhood, so I loved seeing this period depicted. A great movie to bring
one’s kids to. We loved it.
Zero Dark Thirty,
dir by Kathryn
Bigelow © 2013 B
About the CIA and the hunt for Osama bin Laden.
Hitchcock, dir
by Sacha Gervasi © 2012 B
Based on Stephen
Rebello's non-fiction book Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of
Psycho. Hitchcock reads a novel called Psycho by Robert Bloch (based on the crimes of
the serial killer,
Ed Gein),
and is convinced that this should be his next movie. The studio heads are not
convinced, and he decides to finance the film personally. With Anthony Hopkins;
Helen Mirren plays his wife, Alma Reville. I liked this film more than Bob did.
Higher Ground, dir by Vera Farmiga © 2011
Library
DVD. The director plays the adult Corinne, and her youngest sister (21 years
her junior), who had never acted before, plays the teenaged Corinne. Based on a
memoir (This Dark World) by Carolyn
S. Briggs. People are born into, or fall into, or find after much seeking,
religious or spiritual frameworks for their lives. This movie portrayed one of
those frameworks, and one of those lives.
Beginners, dir
by Mike Mills © 2010
Library
CD. Thanks to Alita for this recommendation. Stars Ewan McGregor (who played
James Joyce in the wonderful film Nora),
Christopher Plummer, and Mélanie Laurent. Oliver is in his thirties
when, shortly after his mother’s death, his father came out of the closet (and
tells Oliver, "I don't want to just be theoretically gay. I want to do
something about it."). (Film is set in 2003.) At age 82, Plummer won an
Oscar for this, becoming the oldest person in Academy history to win an
Oscar. (Plummer then told the audience “at birth, I was already rehearsing my
Academy acceptance speech, but it was so long ago mercifully for you I've
forgotten it.") Based on Mike mills’ own family (see ‘Descriptions I
Liked’).
Fruitvale Station, dir by Ryan Coogler © 2013 B
Dramatization of the shooting
of Oscar Grant III on New Year’s Eve 2008 at the Fruitvale Station of the
Oakland subway, and the events that led up to it.
Dallas Buyers Club, dir
by Jean-Marc Vallée B
We saw this with Eva and
Herman and Sheila in Boston over Thanksgiving. I’m really glad I saw it, and
have enjoyed reading about Ron Woodroof (wonderfully played by Matthew McConaughey
in the film). See ‘Movie-related Quotes.’
American Hustle,
dir by David o. Russell © 2013 B
Our second David O. Russell film
this year (see Silver Linings Playbook).
He’s found a winner with Jennifer Lawrence (not to mention Christian Bale and
Amy Adams). This didn’t sound at all like something I would like (and I was
right), but I started hearing such rave reviews that I had to satisfy my
curiosity. At the beginning of the film we are told, “Some of.this actually happened.”
It is based on the FBI Abscam operation (“a blemish on the reputation of the
FBI and the American justice system”).
Captain Phillips,
dir by Paul Greengrass B
I think the real life Captain
Phillips had a lot of hubris and ignored data about attacks to other ships off
the coast of Somalia in 2009. Apparently he wasn’t exactly the hero the film
portrays him as. (I have heard about a new documentary in which
Abduwali Abdukhadir Muse, the head hijacker played in the movie by Barkhad
Abdi, also claims that his story hasn’t been told.) Having said that, it was a
movie worth watching.
All the King’s Men, dir by Robert Rossen © 1949 B
Library DVD. This swept the
1949 Oscars. I didn’t read the Robert Penn Warren classic, but it is on my
list. Mercedes McCambridge has the lead female role. The main story is a thinly
disguised version of the rise and assassination of real-life 1930s Louisiana
Governor, Huey Long.
** Original Screenplays **
(not, as far as I know, based on actual events)
Precious: Based on the Novel “Push” by Sapphire, dir by Lee Daniels © 2009 B
Push was
written in 1997 and was Sapphire’s debut novel. This won two Academy Awards and
made a star of Gabourey Sidibe. The story of the character Precious is based
upon a number of young women the author encountered when she worked as a
literacy teacher in Harlem and the Bronx. I haven’t read the book, but based on
the movie, I think she (and director Lee Daniels and screenwriter Geoffrey
Fletcher) did a good job of capturing how a person can be caught in a downward
spiral.
Monsieur Lazhar,
dir by Philippe Falardeau © 2011 B
Library DVD. The teacher
reminded me of Tom Heller. The children who played Alice and Simon (pupils
particularly affected by their previous teacher’s suicide) were charming. The film was selected as
the Canadian entry for the Best Foreign Language Film
at the 2012 Academy Awards, and became one of the five
nominees. The screenplay was developed from a one-character play.
Arbitrage, written
and dir by Nicholas Jarecki © 2012
Library DVD. If you can
overlook that fact that some parts were confusing (such as what agreement,
exactly, his wife had drawn up and wanted him to sign) this is worth seeing. I
watched it again with the director’s commentary, and was impressed by the
energy and confidence of Nicholas Jarecki. (He was born in 1979. This is his
first feature film. At 16, he was hired as a technical consultant on the movie Hackers.) All the actors were
interesting to watch: Richard Gere as the hedge-fund manager, Tim Roth (Pulp Fiction, Rob Roy) as the cop
investigating, and Nate Parker as the young black man who gets embroiled in the
events.
Reckless, dir
by Sarah Harding and David Richards B
Library DVD. A Masterpiece Theatre production from
1998, in three 90-minute episodes. Dr. Owen Springer, who is in his 30s, begins
a new job in Manchester, under head surgeon Dr. Richard Crane. He falls for an
older woman (in her 40s), Anna Fairley, only to find out later that she is the
wife of Dr. Crane. (Similar to the Grey’s
Anatomy basic story line.) Dr. Crane is played by Michael Kitchen, which is
why we sought this out.
Enough Said,
dir and written by Nicole Holofcener © 2013
I saw this romantic comedy at
The Little on their free night for members. With only a split second to decide
what to do, Julia Louis-Dreyfus lets a critical moment pass when she could have
admitted that she very much liked a guy who was being described as a loser.
This film does a nice job of playing out a common situation, where one keeps
silent because something feels too embarrassing to admit. Oh what a tangled web
we weave! James Gandolfini, in one of his final film roles, plays Albert.
* I Might Have Skipped These *
Silver Linings Playbook, dir by David O. Russell © 2012 B
Bob,
who had a higher tolerance than I did for this movie, looked up the woman who
plays the love interest (Jennifer Lawrence) and found she had been the girl who
starred in Winter’s Bone. He
predicted we’ll be seeing a lot more of her. That was confirmed, as she won
Best Actress for the role (age 22—second-youngest Best Actress winner). I hear
she is scheduled to play Jeannette Walls in the film adaptation of Walls' memoir The Glass Castle. I surely look forward
to that!
Troy, dir by Wolfgang Petersen © 2004 B
Library
DVD. Set in 1250 B.C., during the late Bronze age. I got this because a friend
of Eva’s recommended it highly, and also because I had read that Peter
O’Toole’s scene as king begging for his son’s body was “the most moving screen
moment of the year.” Bob ended up watching it alone (after I bailed), so the
next day I asked him what he thought of the king’s scene begging for his son.
He had not thought of that as a stand-out scene. We fast-forwarded through the
film together, so that we could watch that scene. (It didn’t move me, but then
I didn’t have the context.).
The Great Gatsby, dir by Baz Luhrmann © 2013
I was kind
of curious, after reading various comments on imdb, so I went to this when The
Little was having a free movie night for members. I’ve never read the book. I
hope it is better than the movie.
Frances Ha, dir by Noah Baumbach © 2013 B
I
enjoyed becoming familiar with Greta Gerwig (born 1983). But, neither of us was
crazy about this movie. The screenplay was co-written by the director and
Gerwig.
A Face in the Crowd, dir by Elia Kazan © 1957 B
Library
DVD. We got this after reading that it was the photographer William Eggleston’s
most influential film. (It was Lee Remick’s first film. Patricia Neal is also
quite charming in it, and William Eggleston was 19 when it hit the screens, so
that explains a lot.) It was fun to watch Andy Griffith, pre-Mayberry.
Chocolat, dir by Lasse Hallström © 2000
Library
DVD. Had heard about this for years. Not a favorite of mine.
Oslo, August 31, dir by Joachim
Trier © 2011
Library
DVD. Very depressing and unenlightening. Young man (34) has been in residential
rehab for six months (to kick a drug habit). He goes out on leave to spend a
day in Oslo for a job interview and makes one last desperate attempt to connect
with his sister and with an old friend. I already knew that trying to kick a
drug habit and start over is really hard, and this added nothing to my
understanding.
*******************************************
Movie-related
Quotes
*******************************************
Foyle’s War
It's
a pity there was no space in the script for the submersible canoe, the
exploding camel dung or the Spigot Gun—all devised by the scientists at Station
1X.
– creator and writer Anthony Horowitz, commenting on the
SOE (Special Operations Executive), a top-secret organization whose aim was to
undermine Hitler's Europe by means of sabotage and subversion, and which was
portrayed in the episode The French Drop.
Dallas Buyers Club
I’d heard rumors about a film, but I was never contacted.
And then a few weeks ago I was watching Gravity with my son and suddenly
there was the trailer for Dallas Buyers Club. My jaw dropped. I thought,
“Well, I guess those rumors were for real.”
–
Bill Minutaglio. Bill was a reporter for the Dallas Morning News in the summer of 1992 when he stumbled
upon an article about AIDS patients in cities across the country who were pooling
their resources and paying local entrepreneurs to supply them with drugs not
yet approved by the FDA. Minutaglio tracked down the local club, met Ron Woodroof,
and got him to relate all his exploits. Minutaglio’s article, “Buying Time,” appeared
in the Morning News’ Sunday magazine. It was the first profile of Ron
Woodroof anyone had ever done. Shortly after Minutaglio’s story appeared,
screenwriter Craig Borten drove to Dallas and spent three days talking to
Woodroof. It was 20 years before the film was made. Craig Borten and Melisa
Wallack have the screenplay credits.
*******************************************
Reviews or Descriptions I
Liked
*******************************************
Precious: Based on the Novel “Push” by Sapphire
Precious received six nominations [in 2009], including one for
Best Picture, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best
Supporting Actress (for Mo'Nique).
Scott
Mendelson of the Huffington Post felt that when you put the "glaring issues aside," the film
"still works as a potent character study and a glimpse inside a world we'd
rather pretend does not exist in America." But while the film
"succeeds as a powerful acting treat and a potent character study, there
are some major narrative issues that prevent the film from being an accidental
masterpiece.”
Beginners
At
the beginning I didn’t know what it was going to be. I just knew I wanted to
make something about my parents’ decisions; how love and sex and relationships
are historical; how the personal is political. When my dad died, I became so
interested in their marriage—why it happened,
how the fuck it happened. (a quote from
Mike Mills, director)
Zero Dark Thirty
[Bigelow was] milk[ing] the U.S.
torture program for drama while sidestepping the political and ethical debate
that it provoked.
–
Jane Mayer of The New Yorker
The Topp Twins
You
may never have heard of Jools and Lynda Topp, country-singing lesbian twins
from New Zealand, but it’s not because of their retiring personalities.
Boisterous, big-voiced and built to last, these musical sisters have carved
successful careers by doing what most people only dream of: that is, exactly as
they please. That much and more is made ebulliently clear in Leanne Pooley’s unabashedly
admiring documentary about a double act that defies logic as much as convention.
Merging old-fashioned comedy routines with up-to-the-minute politics—all of it
enabled by fun-loving personalities and a gift for rousing original songs—the ladies
emit a genuine warmth that reels audiences in.
–
Jeannette Catsoulis, The New York Times
New Zealand's finest export since lamb cutlets.
– The Herald, Glasgow
Monsieur Lazhar
[This
film] sustains an exquisite balance between grown-up and child’s-eye views of
education, teacher-student relations and peer-group interactions.
–
Stephen Holden, The New York Times
Higher Ground
Every religious group and every religious leader
must ask one simple question of our faith and practice: does it harm or does it
heal? With subtlety and excellence, the film Higher Ground asks us to think on these things.
– Marilyn Sewell,
UU Minister, writing for huffingtonpost.com
The Queen of Versailles
[W]e never got more insight beyond the observation that some people have too much money and some too little.
–
David Bowden,
spiked-online.com, Feb 2013
It’s unclear how Siegel thought he would be portrayed in the film—he
presumably had some kind of "free market superhero" in mind—but
for
any future billionaire who plans to let a documentarian film the
karmic result of his rapacious greed, let this be a lesson: Don’t be
so surprised when the final product doesn’t make you look so good.
–
Austin Bernhardt,
Jan 25, 2013
42
Jackie
Robinson: You want a player
who doesn't have the guts to fight back?
Branch Rickey:
No. I want a player who's got the
guts *not* to fight back.
Jackie
Robinson: You give me a uniform,
you give me a number on my back, I'll give you the guts.
Arbitrage
Miller
practices moral arbitrage in his life, weighing the penalties of lying to his
family against the losses from a blown business deal; he’s a hyper-rational man
who keeps on calculating everything he does until he winds up in a void. … It’s his [Richard Gere’s] best
performance yet.
–
David Denby, The New Yorker
Heaven’s Gate
This
3.5-hour movie was playing at The Dryden in August. But I decided not to see it
(even though The Dryden’s version was “The Director’s Cut,” and newly restored)
after reading this review that Roger Ebert gave in 1980, when the film was new:
“This movie is $36 million thrown to the winds. It is the most scandalous
cinematic waste I have ever seen, and remember, I've seen Paint Your Wagon.”
Homeland
Homeland, this season, has departed plausibility long ago.
Wouldn’t terrorists realize that a black van following them is not a good
thing? A full-service, well-stocked tailor shop on the main street in
Gettysburg? Maybe don’t take a phone call from your wife when you are about to
break someone’s neck? Wait, what, Carrie is going into the tunnel herself to
get Nazir? It’s easy to pick up any loose thread in Homeland and quickly find yourself in a laughable scenario. Yet,
there I was, each week, watching.
–
excerpt from The New Yorker Dec 17, 2012, by Michael
Agger
Forks Over Knives
Even
as a vegan, I still find that when I read about passionate and influential
advocates of this diet, my defenses go up, as if on fanaticism-alert. So I
found it really great to see and hear these people speak and see that they
really are normal people, just like you and me.
–
Matt Frazier, No Meat Athlete: Runs on Plants
American
Hustle
Lawrence here lets rip in a terrifically ballsy supporting
role; part harpy, part siren, a vision of steely defiance with an undercurrent
of cracked exasperation.
–
Mark Kermode in The Observer Dec 21, 2013
The Trials of Muhammad Ali
At a time when most professional athletes tend to
be either self-absorbed jerks or people unwilling to take any sort of stand for
fear of jeopardizing any endorsement deals, to see one brave enough to fight
just as hard out of the ring as he did inside of it makes The Trials of Muhammad Ali a unique and inspiring viewing experience.
– Peter Sobczynski
*******************************************
Movie
Miscellany
*******************************************
Excerpts from Roger Ebert [RE]
interview (2006) with Michael Apted [MA] about the Up series:
MA: Up to 42
we did on film (change rolls every 10 minutes; kept having to stop and start;
hard to keep focused). Now I can shoot very long interviews (38 minutes without
stopping; more intimate—not a lot of crew around). Change of technology has
been very very interesting and useful to me.
Tony—from
bafflement to confidence and happiness. He embraces life; he's so enthusiastic,
he's so full of everything. It's tiring being around him sometimes.
RE: When he was
21, you were convinced he was going to be a [didn’t catch the word; but, in
context, it was something like “ne’re do well”]."
MA: Yes, I
was. It's this terrible, terrible impulse to play God. Which is one of the
attractions of the thing. It's fun for you. But, if I make the next film with
some agenda, then it will become a self-fulfilling prophecy. I tried to predict
what was going to happen to Tony. I tried to predict what was going to happen
to Nick's marriage. Once I was right, once I was wrong. But, it was a foolish
thing to do, I think.
RE: You ask
Neil if he might be going mad. That's a tough question to ask, and he answers
it very seriously: he's afraid he might be. We're afraid he might be too. So,
we’re grateful that you have that relationship with him that allows that
question to be asked.
MA: People say,
'Is this a portrait of England?' I say, 'This is a portrait of people who were
born in 1956, of that generation.' It's very hard to draw a conclusion—a
definitive view—of English society. That was the great kind of metamorphosis
that the film and I went through. It definitely started out with a political
agenda. It was a very socialist, left-wing company, Granada Television, working
on a very provocative program, World in Action.
Social barriers shouldn't exist. They are a great waste of people's time and
talent. The humanity of the film came out after 21 when we'd kind of grown through all that.
RE: ‘63 [the
year 7 Up was made] is that year
that Larkin says [here he quotes Larkin, see below]. ‘63 was The Beatles. And,
that year, for many people, represents the difference between people wearing
suits and ties and everything since.
Sexual
intercourse began
In nineteen sixty-three
(which was rather late for me) -
Between the end of the "Chatterley" ban
And the Beatles' first LP.
-
from Annus Mirabilis, by Philip
Larkin (1922-1985)
MA: England was
waking—we were hoping—from a big sleep. Maybe there was a brave new world out
there. But, for the everyday life of people, the class system was very
much alive and well. It was us and them. The empowered and the unempowered. That's
what's thrilling about the film. That generation—it was possible to break
through. And it was my good luck—I'm 15 years older than them—that I was able
to document that. America woke up after Eisenhower, with Kennedy, and I documented
that generation. I hit a period when it did change very dramatically. My film,
in a way, is a history of that.
RE: The returns
are in. They can see that this film they were in was a wonderful opportunity. They're
happier now than they've ever been, as a group. And they're wiser.
MA: Whatever has
happened, has happened. They behaved with dignity throughout, and they were
treated with dignity. These stories elevate the ordinary life. … Much more
powerful—dare I say?—than a book. Just to see these people. Human history. Film
does that so brilliantly. There is so much information coming at you out of the
corner of your eye.
RE: I think
it's the most noble use of film that I've been able to witness as a film-goer.
Noble in its simplicity and its honesty and its directness. Just the gaze of an
interested observer coming into these lives and saying “How're you doin'?”
Filmmaker
statement [from the 56 CD extra
features]: 21 Up was full of hope. 28 was about children and
responsibility. 35 was concerned
with mortality, when some were losing parents, and 49 had a sense of disappointment with lives maybe not fully
achieved. Yet 56 is quite different
again, which goes to prove, if nothing else, that our series mirrors life, and
is always full of surprises.
Irena Sendler
The
ghetto-bench system [at Warsaw University] stated that Jewish students were
forced to sit in the left section of a lecture halls; otherwise they would be
expelled. Irena had strong loyalties towards her Jewish friends. In the 1930’s
Irena stood up and went to sit on the Jewish side of the classroom. When the
teacher told her to move she replied “I am Jewish today.” This led to her being
immediately expelled. (Decades later,
under Communist rule her son and daughter were not allowed to attend the Warsaw
University due to Irena’s actions.)
- http://irenasendleressay.weebly.com/early-childhood.html
In
2007, it was widely reported that Irena Sendler was nominated for the Nobel
Peace Prize. She lost to Al Gore. (Over time, many individuals have become
known as "Nobel Peace Prize Nominees," but this designation has no
official standing because the list is not made public until 50 years have
passed.) Other notable Nobel omissions: "The greatest omission in our
106-year history is undoubtedly that Mahatma Gandhi never received the Nobel
Peace prize. Gandhi could do without the Nobel Peace prize; whether the Nobel
committee can do without Gandhi is the question." (Quote is from the secretary
of the Nobel Committee, 2006.)
Soul of a People: Writing America's Story
Voice-over:
"The agency had to find writers nationwide. Not just a few scribes in
Washington. They had thousands of slots to fill in quick succession, all
without any idea what that work would be. Word went out through every channel.
A Montana professor relayed the news to a colleague living in a remote cabin in
the Idaho mountains. Vardis Fisher was leery of The New Deal and, like many
Americans, deeply suspicious of the government. Still, hunger won out."
[Words of Vardis Fisher] "It looks now like I will supervise the Writers’
Project in Idaho. I feel absurd going into this work. But when a man is financially
against a wall and has two sons, he does absurd things. ... I received a wire
from Washington telling me to put on 20 writers at once."
The chief of the labor division asked him, "Will 20 truck drivers do?
They've travelled around a lot and seen a lot of things."
"I told him we need 20 Kiplings or Hemingways. They said they had a lot of
clerks. So, they sent me 20 clerks. The next day I got another telegram [from
Henry Alsberg, head of the agency in Washington]: "Put on 20 more writers.
STOP. In two weeks put on 10 more. STOP."
I wired
back, "I am sitting on packing box. STOP. No writers in Idaho. STOP.""
Last revised: January 15, 2014